Evidence against Werewolf

[Radioactive Superstar]

http://www.actuarialoutpost.com/actuarial_discussion_forum/showthread.php?p=2297743#post2297743

He's early on the anti-alt bandwagon. It's not really evidence either way, but he had been active in the pregame but did not comment on all the alts until after the game began. Doesn't make him more likely to be EC, but if he _is_ EC then it probably means his team was fairly light on alts.

[Radioactive Superstar]

Again, not evidence, but if he _is_ EC1 then this discussion of EC1E in chat:
http://www.actuarialoutpost.com/actuarial_discussion_forum/showthread.php?p=2308182#post2308182
probably means no EC1 were in chat. It would have been too dangerous otherwise. You want to give the appearance of putting your teammates in harm's way. This sort of bandwagon had a good chance of taking off and taking down multiple players.

[Radioactive Superstar]

He has voted for dead people a few times now. Cast a vote for sigma shortly after someone else had done so and been publicly corrected.

This might explain part of that...
http://www.actuarialoutpost.com/actuarial_discussion_forum/showthread.php?p=2323611#post2323611

I'm going to have to agree with Will Durant's complaint about the signal-to-noise ratio in this game. It makes it harder to keep track of the game, and it makes the game less fun. For example, having to go back twenty pages and still being unable to find the original post mentioning the guitar alliance lynch mob?

It's even worse that there are too few posts by the EC, making it hard to get any feel for who they are.

[Radioactive Superstar]

Is one of the people I have pegged as a likely EC1 leader, along with Pirate Kitty, Kohl, and Skizzmata. Not evidence against him particularly, but I do believe he has the skillz to pull it off and that's a fairly small group of people.
Of course, one of those people would be AA, and who knows what sort of tips the EC-hugger has been passing on, which could cloud the waters a bit.

[Abstract Actuary]

EC-hugger :lol: I like that. Better than dirty EC collaborator, although that one has some history and is also pretty good.

[Radioactive Superstar]

EC-hugger :lol: I like that. Better than dirty EC collaborator, although that one has some history and is also pretty good.

watch it buddy. You're quickly moving up to the hallowed "codnocker" status. :lol:

[Radioactive Superstar]

I think that's about all I can find on Werewolf at the moment. All in all, I'd say the evidence isn't piled very high though I think he is still one of the better shots as the hypothetical EC1 leader.
(i.e. IFF we decided to go after the EC1 leader, he is the candidate I would support. I think the "likelihood of being EC" for each of the other candidates might be higher).