snafu
03-14-2005, 06:45 AM
OK, apologies if this is alreay in here somewhere but I couldn't find it.
Please list the remaining students in order from Most Guilty to Most Innocent with reasons.
Last Train to Skaville - Most Likely to Be EC
has jumped in on several occassions to finish a lynching
focus on urysohn (whom I believe is innocent)
sent me a PM (that I can't share) accusing urysohn that was the lamest accusation I have ever heard
Perfectly safe voting except with a tendency to finish the kill
Block voting with Werewolf and Travis in rounds 2 and 4
Travis
increased enthusiasm versus prior game (maybe due to a more interesting role?)
block voting with Last Train and Werewolf in rounds 2 and 4)
other minorly suspicious voting patterns
Werewolf
block voting with Last Train and Travis in rounds 2 and 4
Tendency to stay quiet and with the pack (not unusual for him)
Macroman
Some unusual voting with initial votes for the LT/Travis/Werewolf group and then unvoting later
Butters
think innocent b/c willing to vote outside of bandwagon and usual suspects
J.T.
think innocent b/c Round 2 Vote Swap from EB to Bicycle Repairman (why would EC jump off of a bandwagon without a good reason?)
All Clear
think innocent b/c willing to vote outside of bandwagons and usual suspects also being a little more active with commentary (which is something different from last game that I know All Clear had planned on doing). All Clear was slayer two games ago when I was an early-entry into the Ghost Forum and thus knows how to keep a low profile. The fact that he isn't makes him more likely to be innocent in my opinion.
Bicycle Repairman
No way EC draws that much attention that early. Also voting has been all over the place which is not EC-optimal strategy either.
Urysohn - most likely innocent
Repeated calls for Last Train to me mean only one of the two is EC
Unvoted Spidurman in order to ensure the ghosts got their turn (could have easily stayed offline, drawn no attention, and let the chips fall where they may)
Stuck his neck out to swing the voting off me in Round 5 (b/c he listened to the evidence and PM exchange and was convinced of my innocence)
Please list the remaining students in order from Most Guilty to Most Innocent with reasons.
Last Train to Skaville - Most Likely to Be EC
has jumped in on several occassions to finish a lynching
focus on urysohn (whom I believe is innocent)
sent me a PM (that I can't share) accusing urysohn that was the lamest accusation I have ever heard
Perfectly safe voting except with a tendency to finish the kill
Block voting with Werewolf and Travis in rounds 2 and 4
Travis
increased enthusiasm versus prior game (maybe due to a more interesting role?)
block voting with Last Train and Werewolf in rounds 2 and 4)
other minorly suspicious voting patterns
Werewolf
block voting with Last Train and Travis in rounds 2 and 4
Tendency to stay quiet and with the pack (not unusual for him)
Macroman
Some unusual voting with initial votes for the LT/Travis/Werewolf group and then unvoting later
Butters
think innocent b/c willing to vote outside of bandwagon and usual suspects
J.T.
think innocent b/c Round 2 Vote Swap from EB to Bicycle Repairman (why would EC jump off of a bandwagon without a good reason?)
All Clear
think innocent b/c willing to vote outside of bandwagons and usual suspects also being a little more active with commentary (which is something different from last game that I know All Clear had planned on doing). All Clear was slayer two games ago when I was an early-entry into the Ghost Forum and thus knows how to keep a low profile. The fact that he isn't makes him more likely to be innocent in my opinion.
Bicycle Repairman
No way EC draws that much attention that early. Also voting has been all over the place which is not EC-optimal strategy either.
Urysohn - most likely innocent
Repeated calls for Last Train to me mean only one of the two is EC
Unvoted Spidurman in order to ensure the ghosts got their turn (could have easily stayed offline, drawn no attention, and let the chips fall where they may)
Stuck his neck out to swing the voting off me in Round 5 (b/c he listened to the evidence and PM exchange and was convinced of my innocence)