Divergence of the harmonic series, in a probability context
Posted 01272009 at 11:42 PM by Marid Audran
Updated 02072009 at 12:54 AM by Marid Audran (Adding a remark that it's not obvious)
Updated 02072009 at 12:54 AM by Marid Audran (Adding a remark that it's not obvious)
I thought of this while reading in Rosenthal's book about the BorelCantelli lemma and trying to think up an example.
I learned a long time ago that the harmonic seriesdiverges to infinity. Nonetheless, when I thought of the following example (which boils down to this fact), it felt less than completely intuitive to me.
Consider an infinite sequence of real numbers , where each number is chosen randomly from the interval with the uniform distribution. (Use the Axiom of Choice where appropriate to do this.) What is the probability that infinitely many of the satisfy ? It must be 1!
Edited to add: Rosenthal has an exercise that's similar to this example. Imagine an infinite sequence of integers, where the nth integer is chosen randomly from the set {1,2,...,n} with the uniform distribution. What is the probability that the sequence contains infinitely many 5's?
Edited to add: I realized that my example is not as "obvious" as I might have thought it was. For one thing (in fact, this may be the only thing), my example depends on the fact that the x_i are independent. (The independence is why BorelCantelli can be used here.) Taken by itself, the fact that the individual probabilities sum to infinity does NOT imply that "infinitely many are true" has probability 1. Indeed, consider an alternate experiment: Suppose is chosen randomly from (0,1) and all , are equal to . What is the probability that infinitely many of the satisfy ? It must be zero!
I learned a long time ago that the harmonic seriesdiverges to infinity. Nonetheless, when I thought of the following example (which boils down to this fact), it felt less than completely intuitive to me.
Consider an infinite sequence of real numbers , where each number is chosen randomly from the interval with the uniform distribution. (Use the Axiom of Choice where appropriate to do this.) What is the probability that infinitely many of the satisfy ? It must be 1!
Edited to add: Rosenthal has an exercise that's similar to this example. Imagine an infinite sequence of integers, where the nth integer is chosen randomly from the set {1,2,...,n} with the uniform distribution. What is the probability that the sequence contains infinitely many 5's?
Edited to add: I realized that my example is not as "obvious" as I might have thought it was. For one thing (in fact, this may be the only thing), my example depends on the fact that the x_i are independent. (The independence is why BorelCantelli can be used here.) Taken by itself, the fact that the individual probabilities sum to infinity does NOT imply that "infinitely many are true" has probability 1. Indeed, consider an alternate experiment: Suppose is chosen randomly from (0,1) and all , are equal to . What is the probability that infinitely many of the satisfy ? It must be zero!
Total Comments 1
Comments

a (somewhat vague) application of your example is abiogenesis. Suppose the universe is infinitey large and roughly uniform, and that the probability of life forming on a planet chosen at random is P=10^100.
Then there are with P=1, an infinite number of aliens out there.Posted 01282009 at 01:12 PM by sweetiepie