If A,B,C are independent, then AnB (resp., AuB) and C are independent
Posted 02-02-2009 at 01:12 AM by Marid Audran
(Using n for intersection and u for union, since the built-in TeX is terrible with those symbols.)
Oddly enough, Rosenthal's probability book doesn't seem to even point this out, and my other probability book (Hogg/Craig, from several years back) doesn't see fit to prove it or make a big deal of it. I think it's a big deal. If I've got it right, then I think the proof helps explain why "independence" is defined as a distinct phenomenon from "pairwise independence."* If you only have {A,B},{B,C}, and {A,C} independent, then {AuB,C} might not be independent.
Suppose A, B and C are independent events. Then
P((A u B) n C) = P((A n C) u (B n C))

* In other words: In order for more than two events to be independent, it's not enough that any two of them be independent in the P(AnB)=P(A)P(B) sense. Instead, the probability of the intersection must equal the product of the probabilities for any finite subcollection of events, e.g.: P(AnBnC) = P(A)P(B)P(C).
Oddly enough, Rosenthal's probability book doesn't seem to even point this out, and my other probability book (Hogg/Craig, from several years back) doesn't see fit to prove it or make a big deal of it. I think it's a big deal. If I've got it right, then I think the proof helps explain why "independence" is defined as a distinct phenomenon from "pairwise independence."* If you only have {A,B},{B,C}, and {A,C} independent, then {AuB,C} might not be independent.
Suppose A, B and C are independent events. Then
P((A n B) n C) = P(A n B n C) = P(A)P(B)P(C) = P(A n B) P(C),so that AnB and C are independent. Also, applying some basic set theory, we have
P((A u B) n C) = P((A n C) u (B n C))
= P(A n C) + P(B n C) - P(A n B n C)so AuB and C are independent also.
= P(A)P(C) + P(B)P(C) - P(A)P(B)P(C)
= (P(A)+P(B)-P(A n B))P(C) = P(A u B)P(C),

* In other words: In order for more than two events to be independent, it's not enough that any two of them be independent in the P(AnB)=P(A)P(B) sense. Instead, the probability of the intersection must equal the product of the probabilities for any finite subcollection of events, e.g.: P(AnBnC) = P(A)P(B)P(C).
Total Comments 0
Comments
Recent Blog Entries by Marid Audran
- Found a job outside the industry (04-29-2009)
- If A,B,C are independent, then AnB (resp., AuB) and C are independent (02-02-2009)
- Probability theory textbook: Secret weapon or red herring? (02-01-2009)
- Note to self: Read "Qualifications" list in job postings from the bottom upward (01-28-2009)
- Divergence of the harmonic series, in a probability context (01-27-2009)




