
#1




Panning Hidden Formulas
Do you think we would need to know formulas in the background used to generate Table 1 modified durations?
For example, to calculate the modified duration of Premiums: PV(P) = P * d/(1d). Given that P as stated at the end of section 2 on page 6, both d and P depend on y. Using natural logarithm of PV(P) and taking the derivative with respect to y gives the negative duration. Thus the modified duration for premium is given by [ (1+k)S + L ] / [ P (1+y)^2 ] + 1 / (1+ycr) = [ (1.15)(50) + 75 ] / [ (101.19) (1.05)^2 ] + 1 / (1.05  0.90) = 132.5 / 111.562 + 1 / 0.15 = 7.854. Similar approach for losses and expenses remembering to use PV(L) = 71.429 instead of just L = 75 since each of these are at time =0. Note this same approach of using the derivative of ln(F) is useful for obtaining a modified duration formula of the franchise value quickly (produces equivalent formula; can be made into formula in text using algebra) with only memorization of F. 
#2




Discovered a shorter form of the current economic value as
C = (1+k)S/(1+y) once you substitute for P in the equation. Both this version and Panning's are intuitive to remember. However this form confirms that it is the amount surplus grows above the risk free rate. 
#3




Another for total value T = C + F = (1 + k  cr) S / (1 + y  cr) after taking the above expression for C and combining with F on page 7 substituting for d as cr / (1+y).
This interestingly shows detentions impact to the total compared to if it was not considered. Quick formulas if you need time. 
#4




However do not use the duration implied by this formula since the text uses a dollar weighted average for duration of total value between current and franchise values.
Example following Goldfarb's questions in his manual I get total duration = 5 using the formula implied from above whereas using the dollar durations gives 5.53. 
#5




Found out why...
Author assumes durations of assets and liabilities 1.0 and .9523 respectively. Assets defined as A = P+SE = S (1+k)/(1+y) + L/(1+y) so that the duration of assets is 1/(1+y)  1 / (1+a+by) + 1/(1+y) = 1.0352. This difference leads to why the text result for duration of total value 5.563 is different from 5 obtained using the formulas above. Note using duration of current value 0.0828 derived from above instead of 1.062 gives (54.76 * 0.0828 + 45.24 * 10.952)/100 = 5.0 I guess this means for the exam I will do it the way shown in the text and not calculate durations for current and total value as above. Last edited by Doc; 04302016 at 10:53 AM.. 
#6




I stumbled onto this thread, which I found Doc's solution really interesting. Can anyone show me the process of the differentiation? Calculus isn't my strongest suit, and I would be really thankful if anyone can show me how it's done?

#8




Yeah, I (think?) am able to get the duration of L and E based on that formula. It's probably a long shot during exam they asked us to this the alternative method to calculate the duration (and differentiate somehow)... but then it's CAS, long shot happens during exam...
I guess the resulting formula [ (1+k)S + L ] / [ P (1+y)^2 ] + 1 / (1+ycr) isn't hard to memorize, and to get the duration of L and E you only need to modify it slightly. 
Thread Tools  Search this Thread 
Display Modes  

