EC #3

[Sotally Tober]

Based no my soul peerings, it is either:

1) Heathen
2) WnC
3) Major Boredom

[dlwktb]

There are actually still 3 EC left. Are we sure it couldn't be one of your other pairings? I just want to make sure we look in every crack before we come to conclusions.

From that list, I like WnC.

[illogic]

WnC sent me a PM early on asking if nmf's alt list was correct about me. Would he have done that if he had EC buddies to ask? I'm leaning toward not.

My first choice is Heathen.

[CindyLou Who]

Originally Posted by illogic

WnC sent me a PM early on asking if nmf's alt list was correct about me. Would he have done that if he had EC buddies to ask? I'm leaning toward not.

My first choice is Heathen.

You may be right, but I'm surprised he hasn't been sending me any PMs (obviously we can't now) No PMs at all to the person that he gave his proxy to 3 times in a row? Very odd. Still not ready to get him yet though.

[Linus]

Originally Posted by CindyLou Who

You may be right, but I'm surprised he hasn't been sending me any PMs (obviously we can't now) No PMs at all to the person that he gave his proxy to 3 times in a row? Very odd. Still not ready to get him yet though.

Last game (when you were both EC) he gave me his proxy a few times with never a PM...

[CindyLou Who]

Originally Posted by Linus

Last game (when you were both EC) he gave me his proxy a few times with never a PM...

Understood, but I'm still surprised.

[CindyLou Who]

And, since we were EC together, he would know I would be looking for telltale signs that he is EC again. I see in the main thread that he's sending PMs to other players. :worried:

[Sotally Tober]

Alright, now that CtC is dead, we're left with 2 EC.

I'm on board with MB being IS. That leaves Heathen/WnC as the other 2. Again, this is based on the assumption that I could accurately see the sleeper.

If I couldn't, 2 people did strange things that might look "suspicious"

1) Buckeye doesn't drop hammer
2) hotdime says she was 99.44% sure about JT. NEVER in my pm's with "The 5" did she indicate this. In fact, I specifically sent out a pm asking which of JT/CtC/sg should I exorcise, and she simply answered "sg". She was the first to answer the question. She never said anything to back up why, she never tried to convince us that JT would be a bad choice.

Granted, they may be doing this to help hide what they know. That seems to be the play right now, given some of the things they've said. I still think we need to hit WnC & Heathen. That is, assuming we get a chance.

[Werewolf]

Originally Posted by Sotally Tober

Alright, now that CtC is dead, we're left with 2 EC.

[Sotally Tober]

OK, scrap it. The results are now worthless, and "The 5" are not really the 5, and the EC will win. I quit.

QED