

FlashChat  Actuarial Discussion  Preliminary Exams  CAS/SOA Exams  Cyberchat  Around the World  Suggestions 
DW Simpson 
Actuarial Salary Surveys 
Actuarial Meeting Schedule 
Contact DW Simpson 
General Actuarial NonSpecific Actuarial Topics  Before posting a thread, please browse over our other sections to see if there is a better fit, such as Careers  Employment, Actuarial Science Universities Forum or any of our other 100+ forums. 

Thread Tools  Display Modes 
#1




Stochastic vs. Deterministic Models
Can anyone please give me a distinction between the two?

#2




With a deterministic model, the assumptions and equations you select "determine" the results. The only way the outputs change is if you change an assumption (or an equation).
With a stochastic model, an element of randomness is introduced at one or many points of the model. Every time you run the model, you get a different result. If you run it many times, this gives you a measure of variability in the process, as predicted by the model.
__________________
Blessed are the flexible, for they shall not be bent out of shape. 
#3




A good example of deterministic models can be found in linear programming: if you want to minimize the cost by choosing how you transport the good from places to places, then you are dealing with a determinstic model for every data you have is fixed beforehand.
As for stochastic models, you may consider the following. If you know on average 5 customers come to bank, then how many servers should you provide so that on average the waiting time per customer is less than 5 mins. Since in this case you can never know exactly how many customers will come, you have to make assumptions on the arrival of the customer like what the distribution is, and whether the arrivals are independent, etc. That's one of the stochastic part of this model. 
#4




 and this is why I don't like the terms deterministic and stochastic models.
We have two answers; both are reasonable, and they don't agree with each other. To highlight why I say they are different, look at Alfred's second example  the queuing theory problem that he says is a stochastic model. It's a stochastic problem, all right  we are looking at a probabilistic situation. I could use a stochastic model to analyze it  do a simulation, etc., but I can also use standard probability theory to solve most queuing theory problems, and come up with a single definite answer, giving the exact probability distribution of waiting time, etc. By most people's definition (specifically Mobile's) this is not a stochastic model, because I have solved the problem exactly, and if you ask me to do it again, I'll give you the exactly the same answer. For most people, stochastic model means some form of simulation model, for example, a complicated DFA model, or a model for aggregate losses under some setup that can't be calculated easily by direct methods. Mobile Actuary gives the answer I think most in the field would agree with, but based on the dictionary definitions of the terms, I think Alfred has a good claim too. 
#5




You can use standard probability to solve MOST queueing theory problems...that is impressive.

#6




Yes, that was pretty stupid of me. I was thinking of simple models with exponential interarrival times.
I still want an answer to my basic question. I toss a coin  it comes up heads with probability 1/2 and tails with probability 1/2. Is this an example of a stochastic model? If not, why not? If yes, why does anybody make an issue of stochastic versus deterministic models? 
#7




What are some types of stochastic models an actuary can build (eg. interest rate?)? And in what ways will the actuary approach the problem (ie. how to setup the model, calculations, etc.)?

#8




Quote:

#9




Quote:
Quote:
__________________
Blessed are the flexible, for they shall not be bent out of shape. Last edited by Mobile Actuary; 04212005 at 10:11 AM.. 
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  

